Allows Unsafe Drugs to be Fed to Livestock
The FDA continues
to allow use of a dangerous livestock drug banned in 160 countries, including
across Europe, China and Taiwan, even though the agency itself admits that
the chemical is highly toxic to humans.
The drug in question
is known as ractopamine, and it increases the body's synthesis of protein
-- thereby causing animals to bulk up and yield more meat. Ractopamine is
in the family of drugs known as beta-agonists, which contains many asthma
is so dangerous to human health that the FDA requires it to be labeled,
"Not for use in humans. Individuals with cardiovascular disease should
exercise special caution to avoid exposure. Use protective clothing, impervious
gloves, protective eye wear, and a NIOSH-approved dust mask."
three different variants of the drug have been approved for use in U.S.
livestock immediately prior to slaughter. This is the exact opposite of
the rules relating to other livestock drugs, such as antibiotics and hormones,
which must be stopped as slaughter nears.
shown that up to 20 percent of ractopamine given to an animal remains active
in its meat after slaughter. More than 1,700 people were poisoned after
eating ractopamine-fed pigs in 1998, according to the Sichuan Pork Trade
Chamber of Commerce.
Also of concern
is the implications of "adding these drugs to waterways or well water
supplies--via contaminated animal feed and manure runoff -- when this class
of drugs is so important in treating children with asthma," said David
Wallinga, MD, of the Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy.
sold under three brand names, all made by the same company: Paylean, Optaflexx
and Tomax. Paylean is fed to pigs for the last 28 days of their lives, Optaflexx
to cattle for the last 28 to 42, and Tomax to turkeys for the last 7 to
14. According to manufacturer Elanco Animal Health (a division of Eli Lilly),
fully 45 percent of U.S. pigs and 30 percent of non-grass-fed cattle receive
some form of ractopamine.
Elanco was also
the maker of Stilbosol, also known as diethylstilbestrol or DES, an estrogen
drug widely prescribed to pregnant women starting in the 1940s. In 1971,
the drug was shown to cause birth defects, but the company did not cease
production until 1997.
The company also
recently purchased the rights to recombinant bovine growth hormone (rBST),
also known as Posiliac, from Monsanto. Noting this connection, "CounterPunch"
author Martha Rosenberg draws parallels between the approval processes for
rBST and ractopamine.
ractopamine increases profits despite greater livestock death and disability,"
food consumers are metabolic, neurological and carcinogen guinea pigs so
that agribusiness can make a profit. And like rBST, 'Mothers Of Growing
Children' was not marked as a visiting group on the Food Safety and Inspection
Service's public calendar next to the ag lobbyists."
A full one-third
of all Food Safety and Inspection Service meetings in January 2009 took
place with Elanco lobbyists.
have complained that ractopamine induces hyperactivity, muscle damage and
even a 10 percent death rate in their pigs and cattle, a concern confirmed
by a 2003 study published in the Journal of Animal Science.
The FDA even
acknowledged these effects in 2002, when it accused Elanco of concealing
data from the agency. It referenced complaints such as, "animals are
down and shaking," and "pig vomiting after eating feed with Paylean."
requested a complete and accurate list of all your [Good Laboratory Practices]
studies involving Paylean ... . In response, your firm supplied to our representatives
multiple lists which differed in the names of the studies and their status.
In addition, your firm could not locate or identify documents pertaining
to some of the studies," the FDA's Division of Compliance director
Yet none of this
stopped the agency from approving the drug in 2003 for cattle, and then
again for turkeys in 2009.
for this story include: